Kirkland Putter Vs Scotty Cameron

You’re on a quest to perfect your golf swing. The putter can make all the difference. Two names are likely on your radar: Kirkland and Scotty Cameron. But choosing isn’t easy.

Let’s dive into this showdown, exploring everything from pricing, quality, product range, and performance. We’ll dissect the pros and cons, helping you find your ultimate golfing companion.

Ready? Let’s unravel the mystery of Kirkland Putters Vs Scotty Cameron.

Kirkland putter vs Scotty Cameron: which one is better?

When comparing the Kirkland putter to the Scotty Cameron, several factors come into play. You need to consider price, quality, product variety, and legality, among other things.

Let’s conduct a detailed analysis to determine which putter offers the best value for your needs and preferences.

Kirkland putter overview

Kirkland Signature KS1 Putter

✔ Stability and Feel

✔ Quality Construction

✔ Good Feel

✔ Premium Components

New or Used Available 

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Starting with the Kirkland putter, you get a solid, affordable option that packs a punch well above its price tag. Forged from 100% 303 stainless steel, it resembles the pricier Scotty Cameron’s Newport range.

The Kirkland putter boasts a professional-grade CNC milled face insert with a customizable weight kit and adjustable toe/heel weighting system. It also features a comfortable SuperStroke CounterCore mid-slim grip.

However, it’s not without shortcomings. The putter head feels light, which can lead to inconsistent performance. Moreover, it struggles with speed control and close-range shots due to its closed feel and high loft.

Despite these drawbacks, it’s a great entry-level option, offering excellent value for its price.

Scotty Cameron putter overview

Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Putter Newport 2

✔ Precision Milled

✔ Enhanced Feel

✔ Versatile for Various Strokes

✔ Popular on Tour

New or Used Available 

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Now, let’s delve into the details of the Scotty Cameron putter to see how it measures up against the Kirkland option.

The Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2, a traditional Anser blade putter, is known for its excellent feel and feedback, which is expected of a high-end choice. With a club face precision milled from 303 steel and an expertly weighted club head, this putter ensures optimal feel, control, and stability.

Designed with attention to detail, even the plumber’s neck shaft has been redesigned for better alignment. While its $600 price tag might seem steep, it offers the quality and performance that seasoned golfers seek. It’s a reliable blade putter for local golf courses and professional tournaments.

Kirkland KS1 Putter vs Scotty Cameron: Price

Considering the price, you’ll find that the Kirkland KS1 putter, priced at $215, offers a more affordable option than the Scotty Cameron putters, which typically cost around $600. This price difference of about $385 can be significant, especially if you’re budget-conscious or new to the game.

The Scotty Cameron brand commands a premium due to its reputation and widespread recognition in golf. However, while the price tag is steep, it’s important to remember that part of what you’re paying for is the brand prestige and high-quality craftsmanship. Scotty Cameron putters are meticulously designed and handcrafted, using premium materials and precise manufacturing techniques.

On the other hand, the Kirkland KS1 putter, though less recognized, isn’t to be underestimated. It offers excellent value for money, with a high-quality build and advanced features usually found in more expensive putters. Forged from 100% 303 stainless steel and featuring a precision-milled face, the KS1 is a solid contender.

In terms of customization, Scotty Cameron outshines Kirkland with its extensive options, allowing for a more personalized experience. However, Kirkland only offers standard models, limiting adjustability to your preference.

Ultimately, the choice between the Kirkland KS1 and a Scotty Cameron putter boils down to your budget and personal preferences. If price is your primary concern, the Kirkland KS1 is a cost-effective choice that doesn’t compromise on quality. However, if you’re willing to splurge for customization and brand prestige, Scotty Cameron could be worth the investment.

Kirkland KS1 Putter vs Scotty Cameron: Quality

Regarding the quality of the Kirkland KS1 putter versus a Scotty Cameron putter, you’ll find both brands deliver high-grade products. Both manufacturers mill their putters from top-notch metals, ensuring durability and longevity. This means no matter your choice, you’re investing in a long-lasting, high-quality putter.

Delving deeper, both putters boast a milled face, a feature known for its ability to enhance control and consistency on the greens. The Kirkland KS1, for example, is forged from 100% 303 stainless steel, offering a sturdy, reliable putter built to last. Its precision-milled face ensures solid contact and adjustable heel and toe weights allow customization.

However, the Scotty Cameron putters take quality a step further. Known for their meticulous design and craftsmanship, these putters use premium materials and precise manufacturing techniques. The Scotty Cameron Special Select Newport 2 putter features a precision-milled 303 steel face insert, an expertly weighted club head, and a redesigned plumber’s neck shaft for better visibility and alignment.

While the quality of both putters is high, subtle differences might influence your decision. The Kirkland KS1 putter offers excellent value for its price, but its head can feel light, leading to inconsistent performance. On the other hand, the Scotty Cameron putters are renowned for their superior feel and feedback but come with a higher price tag.

Kirkland Putter vs Scotty Cameron Putter: Product Variety

How do Kirkland and Scotty Cameron compare when it comes to the variety of putters they offer?

Kirkland, as a brand, only has one putter available for purchase. This putter is a blade design, which may limit your options if you prefer a different style.

On the other hand, Scotty Cameron boasts a whopping collection of over 100 putters, providing a diverse range of choices to suit various golfers’ preferences.

Kirkland offers a well-designed and affordable option if you’re a fan of blade putters. However, the lack of variety can be off-putting if you want something specific. For instance, Kirkland mightn’t be the best fit if you wish to a putter with a specific loft, length, or weight. This lack of choice can limit you, especially if you’re looking to experiment and find the perfect putter for your unique swing.

Contrastingly, Scotty Cameron’s extensive collection includes both blade and mid-mallet putters. This diversity allows you to find a putter that suits your game, style, and feel. Scotty Cameron covers you whether you prefer a traditional blade putter or a more modern mid-mallet. The brand’s broad range caters to beginners and professionals, offering a putter for every skill level and playstyle.

In the end, Scotty Cameron clearly takes the lead when it comes to variety. However, if a blade putter is what you’re after and budget is a concern, Kirkland’s single offering might be the perfect fit.

Comparison of Kirkland Putter and Scotty Cameron Putter

Now that you’ve seen each brand’s variety, let’s delve deeper into the specific differences and similarities between the Kirkland and Scotty Cameron putters.

The Kirkland putter, priced at an affordable $215, is known for its unique design and construction. With a precision-milled face, multi-material construction, and advanced alignment aids, Kirkland puts a lot of technology into their putters. However, Kirkland provides limited customization options, and the brand isn’t as widely recognized in golf.

On the other hand, Scotty Cameron putters are renowned for their craftsmanship and prestige. Priced at a higher point of $600, they’re meticulously designed and handcrafted using premium materials. A noteworthy feature is their innovative technologies like face inserts and sole weights. Further, Scotty Cameron provides extensive customization options, allowing you to personalize your putter to suit your individual preferences.

In terms of performance, both putters offer forgiveness on off-center hits and a consistent roll. Kirkland’s putter is praised for its smooth and soft feel, while Scotty Cameron’s putter provides a superior feel and feedback.

Legally, both putters conform to all equipment rules the USGA sets and can be used in any golf tournament or match.

Pros and Cons of the Kirkland Putter

Let’s evaluate the Kirkland Putter, considering both its strengths and weaknesses.

As affordable as it is, you may find its exceptional value appealing, but it’s essential also to consider potential drawbacks.

Consider how its performance, design, and features align with your needs and preferences.

Pros of the Kirkland Putter

You’ll find several benefits to the Kirkland Putter that make it a worthy contender.

Its cost-effectiveness is a standout feature, offering high-quality performance at a fraction of the cost of higher-end brands.

With a design focused on forgiveness, advanced alignment aids, and stability, it provides an impressive level of playability for its price point.

Cost-Effective

Why should you consider the Kirkland putter?

This putter is incredibly cost-effective, providing quality at a more affordable price. It’s made using high-quality metals and precision milled, just like pricier putters. Despite its low cost, it’s legal for tournament play, and its solid construction ensures durability.

Its major downside? It doesn’t offer the variety of options that pricier brands do.

Forgiveness

Regarding forgiveness, a significant advantage of the Kirkland putter is its ability to minimize the effects of off-center hits, providing more consistent results on the greens.

Its precision-milled face and multi-material construction contribute to this forgiveness.

You’ll find this putter helps maintain your performance, even when your swing isn’t perfect, offering a level of reliability crucial in a game of precision and finesse like golf.

Alignment Aids

Often, you’ll appreciate the advanced alignment aids incorporated in the Kirkland putter, as they significantly improve your accuracy on the greens.

These aids:

  • Enhance your confidence: You no longer have to guess your putt direction second.
  • Improve overall performance: With accurate alignment, you’ll see a boost in your putting success rate.
  • Assist in precision: Aids in lining up putts accurately, reducing chances of off-target hits.

Stability

Thanks to its design and construction, you’ll appreciate the stability that the Kirkland putter offers. This stability results in a smoother roll and heightened accuracy, making sinking putts easier.

The precision-milled face and adjustable heel and toe weights contribute to this stability, while the SuperStroke CounterCore Mid Slim grip gives you a better hold and control.

Cons of the Kirkland Putter:

While the Kirkland putter offers excellent value, there are some downsides you should consider.

Customization options are limited, which could potentially affect your game’s adaptability.

Moreover, Kirkland’s brand recognition in golfing isn’t as strong, and the putter’s availability can sometimes be inconsistent.

Limited Customization

You might find the Kirkland putter’s options a bit limited in terms of customization.

  • Limited Choices:
  • Only one design is available.
  • There are no options for different types of putters, like mallets.

  • Fixed Specifications:

  • Set loft and club length.

  • Lack of Personalization:

  • No ability to adjust to personal preferences.

This can affect your game if you’re used to more personalized gear.

Brand Recognition

Despite the Kirkland putter’s impressive quality and affordability, it’s essential to consider that its brand recognition may not be as strong as that of more established putter brands like Scotty Cameron.

This relative lack of prestige could be a disadvantage if you value brand reputation. Although Kirkland is gaining traction, it doesn’t yet carry the same weight in the golf community as some competitors.

Availability

As a potential drawback, you might find getting your hands on a Kirkland putter challenging due to its limited availability, particularly during high-demand periods.

Here are a few cons:

  • Limited stock can lead to longer waiting times.
  • High-demand periods may cause prices to spike.
  • The lack of availability can force you to consider other, perhaps less desirable, options.

Pros and Cons of the Scotty Cameron Putter

Now, let’s shift our focus to Scotty Cameron putters.

Known for their superior craftsmanship and high price points, these putters bring unique advantages and disadvantages to the table.

Understanding the pros and cons of Scotty Cameron putters will aid you in figuring out if they’re the right choice for your golf game.

Pros of the Scotty Cameron Putter

You’re likely drawn to the Scotty Cameron putter for its superior craftsmanship, offering a level of detail that’s truly top-tier. The exceptional feel and feedback it provides can enhance your game, allowing for precise shots and better control.

Plus, with extensive customization options and a boost in brand prestige, it’s clear why many golfers favor Scotty Cameron.

Superior Craftsmanship

While you might be put off by the high price tag of Scotty Cameron putters, it’s important to remember that you’re investing in superior craftsmanship. Each putter is meticulously handcrafted using premium materials for a high-quality and visually appealing product.

  • Attention to detail: Every line and curvature is carefully crafted.
  • Premium materials: Quality metals that last and impart an excellent feel.
  • Visual appeal: The putter’s design and finish scream luxury and sophistication.

Exceptional Feel and Feedback

Investing in a Scotty Cameron putter is more than obtaining superior craftsmanship and visual appeal. It also offers an exceptional feel and feedback that can significantly enhance your performance on the green.

A Scotty Cameron putter’s precision manufacturing and advanced face technology result in a soft and smooth impact. This gives golfers excellent feedback, which is crucial for improving their game. The feedback from the putter is instrumental in honing a consistent stroke, allowing players to develop a reliable and accurate putting technique.

A Scotty Cameron putter is not just a stylish accessory for golfers. It is an invaluable tool that can significantly contribute to their golfing arsenal.

Customization Options

Regarding customization options, your Scotty Cameron putter doesn’t disappoint, offering a wide range of tailor-made features to suit your playing style.

  • Head Design: Choose from a variety to match your stroke mechanism
  • Classic blades, mid-mallets, or more giant mallets

  • Neck Type: Options like plumbing neck, short bend, or flow neck

  • Grip Selection: Multiple sizes and textures are available to fit your hand and stroke comfort.

Brand Prestige

Continuing with the customization benefits, your Scotty Cameron putter boasts a substantial brand prestige, often considered a badge of honor among golf enthusiasts for its superior craftsmanship and performance.

This prestige is reflected in the trust placed by top-level players in various tours, affirming its reputation for high-quality, high-performance putters.

Therefore, when you choose a Scotty Cameron, you’re not just buying a putter but investing in a legacy.

Cons of the Scotty Cameron Putter

While the Scotty Cameron putter boasts superior craftsmanship and performance, it’s not without its drawbacks.

The high price point might be a stumbling block for some, not to mention the limited accessibility due to demand.

Moreover, personal preference plays a significant role; its classic design mightn’t appeal to everyone’s taste.

Higher Price Point

One significant downside with the Scotty Cameron putter is its high price point, which can be a barrier if you’re budget-conscious.

  • High Cost:
  • Scotty Cameron putters are pricier compared to other brands like Kirkland.
  • The price is due to the brand’s reputation, exceptional craftsmanship, and attention to detail.

If you’re on a tight budget, you might opt for other more affordable yet quality options like the Kirkland putter.

Limited Accessibility

Despite the prestige associated with Scotty Cameron putters, accessibility can be a severe drawback, especially in specific regions or during periods of high demand. Limited availability can make it challenging to find and purchase your desired model.

This scarcity might make you settle for less preferred options or delay your purchase, impeding your golfing experience and performance.

Personal Preference

Though you may appreciate the high-end reputation of Scotty Cameron putters, there are a few drawbacks you should consider.

  • Firstly, the price is significantly higher than other brands.

  • Secondly, the design and feel may not suit everyone’s preferences.

  • Finally, Scotty Cameron putters are typically blade style, which can be more challenging for beginners.

Considering these factors and deciding what’s most important to you is essential.

Choosing the Right Putter for You

Often, you’ll find that choosing the right putter for you isn’t just about brand prestige or price; it’s about what feels best in your hands and aligns with your play style.

For example, the Kirkland KS1 and Scotty Cameron putters offer premium quality but at different price points, and each has unique features that could suit your game.

If budget is a concern, the Kirkland KS1, priced at $215, is a great value. It’s precision-milled, durable, and has advanced alignment aids. On the other hand, Scotty Cameron putters, with a price tag of around $600, offer over 100 design options, enabling a more personalized selection.

While Kirkland offers one putter style, Scotty Cameron provides blade and mid-mallet putters. If you like non-blade putters, Scotty Cameron might be your match. However, if you prefer blade putters and are looking for an affordable option, Kirkland could be your go-to.

Both brands offer USGA-legal putters, ensuring they can be used at any level of play. So, legality won’t be a concern when choosing between these two brands.

Ultimately, the right putter depends on your preferences, play style, and budget. Try different putters and choose one that feels comfortable and boosts your confidence on the green. Remember, the perfect putter for you is the one that helps you perform your best.

Conclusion

In conclusion, both Kirkland and Scotty Cameron putters have their merits.

Kirkland offers quality at an affordable price, while Scotty Cameron provides unparalleled customization and status.

Your choice hinges on your personal preferences, budget, and playing style.

 

So, take your time, weigh the pros and cons, and choose the putter that will enhance your game and feel like a natural extension of your arm on the green. 

Also, you can try both putters. Visit the nearest golf shop or take advantage of Global Golf’s Utry trial program. I use it and recommend it.

Happy putting!

Kirkland Signature KS1 Putter

✔ Stability and Feel

✔ Quality Construction

✔ Good Feel

✔ Premium Components

New or Used Available 

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

Titleist Scotty Cameron Special Select Putter Newport 2

✔ Precision Milled

✔ Enhanced Feel

✔ Versatile for Various Strokes

✔ Popular on Tour

New or Used Available 

We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.